Neon Tommy - Annenberg digital news

One Year Later, Who Is Riding the Expo Line?

Axel Hellman |
May 1, 2013 | 5:55 p.m. PDT

Staff Reporter

Expo Line passengers /photo credit: stevebott (flickr)
Expo Line passengers /photo credit: stevebott (flickr)

When the Expo Line, Los Angeles Metro’s newest light rail line, opened in April 2012, initial ridership numbers were low, starting at around 11,000 per average weekday, a fact which many media sources reported on. One libertarian think tank even used these low numbers to argue that light rail systems in general should not be built.

But now, one year later, the picture is very different. Ridership on weekdays has been increasing at a steady clip of about 1,000 per month, reaching an estimated 26,000 per day during the week. Given that Metro projected about 27,000 riders per day by the year 2020, that number is very good. The number of people riding the Expo Line may pass that benchmark in the coming months.

A graph of Expo Line ridership per month.  (LA Metro)
A graph of Expo Line ridership per month. (LA Metro)

A Metro spokesperson, Jesse Simon, disputed the line’s naysayers, cautioning that ridership will rise with time, “A favorite tactic of rail critics used to be to take statistics from a year or two after the opening date of a rail [line] to show that out-year estimates of rail patronage were grossly exaggerated. But changing to rail involves a longer process of changing habits. Our experience with rail patronage, and I believe experience elsewhere, is that rail growth is incremental.“

Simon said that in the long term, ridership has been slowly increasing on Metro’s other rail lines, “Rail patronage has increased steadily almost every year since the first line opened in 1990; and not only because more lines came online – within each Line the growth has been steady and it has not reached a stable endpoint.”

So who are these tens of thousands of people who use the line every day? In addition to Downtown commuters, a broad range of people are using the line for work, school and play.

Although not a majority, a significant number of USC faculty and students are using the line to get to campus, “The number of graduate student Metro passes increased from about 500 last year to over 1,500 this year,” says USC ridesharing coordinator Lev Vanshelbaum. “Additionally, the number of staff/faculty that signed up for a Metro TAP pass through USC tripled in the first few months after the line opened.”

Another Metro spokesperson, Jose Ubaldo, says that Metro has been specifically targeting some of its marketing efforts at USC students, offering free tap cards to students and distributing brochures about where the line can take them.  He says that these outreach efforts yielded a "good response."

He explained that Metro also employs seven staffers whose job it is to reach out to employers, and to help them comply with air quality regulations and coordinate employee commuting by using Metro.

Metro also arranged press events and provided free rides when the Expo Line opened in order to introduce the line to Angelenos. But Metro was unable to provide exact demographics about the Metro line or the return on investment from the otureach programs.

Andrew Allport, of Culver City, teaches at USC and normally takes the Expo Line to work. He said that it spares him the troubles of traffic and parking on campus and said, “Before I would bike all the way to work or take a motorcycle. The train is way better."

“The train also gives me the opportunity to read and to grade papers,” he added.

Still, Allport estimates that 85 percent of his colleagues drive to work, saying, “It’s only really convenient if you live in Culver City.”

Younger students are also using the line to get to school. Maria Diaz, a middle school student, used to walk a mile from her school to the Blue Line at Grand, but now takes the Expo Line.

Southern California Public Radio reports that many people are using the line to access entertainment destinations downtown, particularly is the LA Live/Staples Center area, which is near the Expo Line’s Pico station.

And the Daily News has observed a trend of San Fernando Valley residents taking the Red Line and transferring to the Expo Line to get to places on the Westside, in an attempt to avoid traffic.

In the fall, thousands of spectators at USC football games at the L.A. Memorial Coliseum arrive by train, and USC worked with Metro to make fans aware of their options.

The museums in Exposition Park are another major attraction along the line. Many visitors take the train to get there, including many school field trip groups. One such group was led by Shatay Deese, a kindergarten teacher at the Culture and Language Academy of Success on Coliseum Street. She said that it was a cheap alternative, “A school bus would cost like 300 dollars.” It was also fun for the kids, she said, “They did enjoy it. We just need a lot of chaperones to make sure that everyone gets on and off.”

The California Science Center and the Natural History Museum, two museums in Expo Park, offer a discount to visitors who take Metro in an effort to encourage patrons not to drive.

Use of the Expo Line is fairly well distributed along the line. According to  Ubaldo, the three most used stations are all at the ends of the line, at 7th Street/Metro Center, Culver City, and Pico. The 4th, 5th, and 6th most used stations, Vermont, Western, and Crenshaw, are all very close in terms of passengers.

A common criticism of light rail is that it diverts riders from buses and fails to draw drivers out of their cars. Thus, light rail lines can fail to have an impact on traffic and congestion, but can cost hundreds of millions of dollars.

This does not appear to be the case with the Expo Line. Metro’s publicly available ridership statistics show that bus routes that connect with the Expo Line, and routes that run along similar parallel corridors, all have maintained steady ridership numbers.

The Expo Line is being used by tens of thousands every day, and that number is still growing. Metro expects the completed line to Santa Monica to generate 64,000 daily riders by 2030, a goal that is ambitious, but given the success of the first phase of the Expo Line, not unrealistic.

 

Read more Neon Tommy transportation coverage here.

Read more Neon Tommy stories about LA Metro here.

Feel free to contact Axel Hellman here.



 

Live On Twitter

Buzz

Android users barely manage to sue Google for violating their privacy for financial gain.

The FAA has prohibited travel to and from Israel's largest airport for 24 hours. 

 


Comments

doudoune moncler (not verified) on December 30, 2013 1:42 AM

boutique moncler paris prix

Your rating: None
chaussures ugg pas cher (not verified) on December 22, 2013 11:17 PM

doudoune moncler tfou enfants

Your rating: None
E R (not verified) on May 3, 2013 2:21 PM

The best part of that Reason article is in the comments, where on June 12th the author of the piece responded to someone who had the temerity to doubt his conclusions:

"The EIS we consulted says those numbers should come by 2015 at the latest. It is absurd to believe that the ridership will more than double on the basis of opening two stops, but you're welcome to your beliefs."

Less than a year later, that so-called absurdity is *exactly* what has happened. I'd ask him if he felt silly now, but of course he's never going to revisit an old article, especially not when the facts have proven him wrong.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (2 votes)
TOM MURPHY (not verified) on May 3, 2013 7:35 AM

Let's hear it for unanticipated demand for mass transit.

Robert Moses was equally stunned when he opened the Tri-Boro Bridge(pre-WWII) to reduce congestion on the existing East River bridges and the numbers just kept growing at all portals.

Your rating: None
Bob L. (not verified) on May 2, 2013 10:22 PM

The problem of the run time is not Metro or LADOT, but along Flower as an example, the system is set for a given idle time at the station. If this time is met, the trains will move right along. If someone holds the doors open longer than this time, the running will catch the signals "red" (train's horizontal white bar).

Your rating: None
mark j. (not verified) on May 2, 2013 9:26 PM

Remember the Gold line was "slow" to begin with and adjustments were made and the line speed went up and so did ridership. I am sure MTA will sort out the slow section and hopefully before the Santa Monica segment comes on line.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)
Interurbans (not verified) on May 2, 2013 3:45 PM

All of this is spite of the very slow service. It should be 20 minutes from LA to Culver City,not 28 minutes. But as comments say it takes 20 or more minutes to get to just USC. Lets all hope that the MTA and LA DOT have worked together to speed the line up schedule change they will have the line running at a better speed. Also fair inspectors not only would help with security but bring in revenue and help keep the line free of riders who are not actually going to an destination on the line.

Your rating: None
Axel (not verified) on May 2, 2013 3:12 PM

Marc, I completely agree. The speed in that area is a big issue. Sometimes I also take the bus just because I know the train will be slow.

And anonymous, I am not trying to present a biased article. I take the bus pretty often and I have a bus pass. Please contact me with any data that you think I have overlooked.

Your rating: None
Anonymous (not verified) on May 2, 2013 2:51 PM

They should have security on the train. I tried to leave my car at home and take the train from USC to downtown twice, but I got approached by shady people both times. As a lone girl traveler, I will never again ride the train.

Your rating: None Average: 3 (2 votes)
Marc (not verified) on May 2, 2013 1:58 PM

I will say that I am one of those USC graduate students who takes Expo to campus from downtown. However, as of recent I've been taking the bus (81 or Dash F) more and more as the train has been incredibly slow. On a good day - when the train gets to the lights perfectly - it will take 10 min to get from 7th to Expo/USC; the same amount of time as the bus. More recently the train takes nearly 20min. I know having a drunk driver take out a pole near 23rd Street station didn't help things but, the train really needs light priority in the DTLA to USC corridor. Drivers on the 110 North, should look up while they are stuck in traffic and see the Expo train flying by them and wish to themselves that they were on the train. Instead, the train is in as much stop and go traffic as they are.

Your rating: None

Leave a comment

Name
E-mail*
URL
Comments*