Neon Tommy - Annenberg digital news

Second Debate: Romney Wins Six Rounds To Four

Tyler Talgo |
October 16, 2012 | 9:54 p.m. PDT

Contributor

(Barack Obama, Creative Commons)
(Barack Obama, Creative Commons)
Both Mitt Romney and Barack Obama had their strong moments in Tuesday's debate. But, who you think was the winner depends on your political perspective. Romney’s strength was exhibited during the moments when emphasized Obama’s record, and Obama's strength was exhibited by his overall control and more aggressive stance. However, even though he received nine percent less time to speak, it's clear that Romney came out ahead. Here's a dissection of each round:

Question 1 (Jobs after college): Romney.

Romney contrasted the success of Massachusetts’s education system with the last four years under Obama.

Question 2 (Energy): Romney.

This was one of the tensest moments of the debate. Romney stood firm when Obama confronted him, he owned his opinion, and Obama came off as the weaker of the two.

Question 3 (Taxes): Romney.

Obama appeared uncomfortable and Romney will look better among independents, who are solely concerned about the shape of the economy.

Question 4 (Women): Obama.

Romney did better in citing his successes during his tenure as Governor of Massachusetts, but Obama looked more eloquent because of his experience in touting his usual women’s rights narrative.

Question 5 (Bush policies): Obama.

The more Obama’s record is discussed, the better it looks for Romney. But in this question, the focus was solely on Romney and he failed to highlight the differences.

Question 6 (Obama enthusiasm): Romney.

This was one of the strongest moments of the night for Romney, because it completely brought out the attitudes that Americans are currently having.

Question 7 (Immigration): Obama.

Obama was more presidential, while Romney lost control.

Question 8 (Benghazi attack): Obama.

Romney had all the effective arguments that he could have needed, but he didn’t own them. Obama came out ahead when he said that he was offended by the idea of his administration covering up the affair; his initiative is what will be remembered.

Question 9 (Gun Control): Tie.

Both candidates had genuine concerns and there wasn’t much contrast in this round.

Question 10 (Outsourcing): Romney.

Obama focused on Romney’s private sector record, while Romney was more aggressive on China. Romney’s tough stance on China is what will be remembered by independents.

Question 11 (Misconceptions about your character): Romney.

The question was clearly meant for Romney, and he was much more genuine in his answer.

 

Read more of Neon Tommy's coverage of the 2012 Presidential Debate here.

Reach Contributor Tyler Talgo here; follow him here.



 

Live On Twitter

Buzz

L.A. Mayoral Race: Early Results Are In

Will Garcetti's lead stick?

Music Festival Calendar: West Coast Summer 2013

VIDEO: Staying in town this summer? Take a weekend (or two) to check out these other WC festivals.

 


Comments

Pull Armani (not verified) on November 26, 2012 5:02 PM

In the might make technique as a result of an enemy, relay to the situation never a.
[url=http://www.fr-marque.com/]Pull Armani[/url]
Pull Armani

Your rating: None
marazzis on October 17, 2012 9:41 AM

I don't know how you can say Romney won the energy round of the debate. (q2)
Furthermore when it came to outsourcing (q10) - neither candidate made any good points. Honestly - "labeling" china as a currency manipulator? That's Romney's plan? A label - give me a break.

Your rating: None
Smokey (not verified) on October 17, 2012 12:07 AM

Don't bogart that joint, my friend. Pass it over to me.

Your rating: None
Anonymous (not verified) on October 16, 2012 11:12 PM

This is a well-thought-out analysis of the actual issues from someone that is part of the percent of people who say that Romney won, because even according to the polls you're referencing, Ali, the decision was not unanimous among the few hundred people who were polled. So sorry that someone has an analysis of the debate that contrasts with the candidate that won the plurality of the mainstream media in the Opinion section. I hope you haven't signed up to CAST a ballot, Mr. H.

Your rating: None Average: 1 (2 votes)
Ali H. (not verified) on October 16, 2012 11:50 PM

This OpEd is not a "well-thought-out" analysis of any of the "actual issues." There is a header for each of the issues, yes, but there is no justification for any of the ways that the rounds went. I would love for this author to persuade readers with evidence or facts or even moments from the debate that he felt so compelled by -- instead, there is a one line descriptor: "Romney contrasted the success of Massachusetts’s education system with the last four years under Obama." This isn't an opinion, and it doesn't help the reader to understand or be persuaded that Gov. Romney won the debate. The quality of this article is poor, probably because of its prompt publishing after the debate. However, my criticism speaks to the need of the author to INFORM the student electorate of HOW he came to his conclusion, not only what his conclusion is. That is what an Opinion section SHOULD do. Young voters need to be informed more than ever before because as a voting group, we wield more power than ever. And as for your concern about my own voting, Anon, I have not only registered to vote, but I have cast my ballot as well. I hope everyone does, even you. That's why I would like you to have the opportunity to be well-informed.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)
Ali H. (not verified) on October 16, 2012 10:01 PM

CNN and MSNBC say Obama won and Fox News say it was a tie. I'm not sure which debate that Tyler Talgo watched, but I don;t believe that it was the same one that *I* watched... and it would appear that it wasn't the one the anchors of these three major networks watched, either. I hope you haven't signed up to help count ballots, Mr. Talgo.

Your rating: None Average: 5 (2 votes)

Leave a comment

Name
E-mail*
URL
Comments*