Walker's Rejection Of Israeli's Request To Publish "The Color Purple" Misguided Decision

The renowned author may be losing out on some extra overseas fame and fortune, but she has something else on the agenda: by refusing the request, Walker is protesting what she believes to be Israel's gross violation of human rights. However, might she be working against her very cause?
Walker's actions might come as a shock to a lot of us. Most Americans over the age of twelve have heard of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, but we tend to think of Palestine as the bad guys. They're the satanic, land-hungry terrorists who've been attacking innocent Israeli citizens, right? And don't they have ties with al-Qaeda?
Not quite. The Israeli-Palestinian clash is one of the most complicated and long-running conflicts the world has ever seen, and it certainly isn't as one-sided as the United States has historically treated it. It's no secret that United States has consistently acted favorably towards Israel's policies. While this in itself isn't a bad thing, Israel is set up to get away with a whole lot in its fight with the Palestinians when the State Department of a nation as powerful of America recognizes its legitimacy, but not the legitimacy of its opponent.
According to a citizen's tribunal that investigated Israel's activities last year, it would seem that its been doing just that. The tribunal, consisting of human rights activists from around the world, Walker among them, met last fall in South Africa. They determined that Israel was guilty of apartheid, as well as persecution of the Palestinian people, both in Israel and outside - namely, in the Occupied Territories the peace-seeking members of the international community hope to one day see become an independent Palestinian state.
Walker's refusal to allow Yediot Books to publish "The Color Purple" thus comes from a legitimate grievance she has with the nation of Israel. In her official letter to the publisher, which was posted with her permission on the website for the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic & Cultural Boycott of Israel (PCABI), Walker cited another instance in which she acted similarly - when she lobbied against the distribution of the film adaptation of her book in South Africa, which at the time was still practicing apartheid.
Walker's action is in fact directly consistent with PCABI mission, which is to cut Israel off from the gems of international academia and culture, as part of a wider sanctions movement designed to prompt them to treat Palestinians more fairly. And Walker has every right, as creator, to dictate where her art does - and does not - go.
But might this act also be working against her very purposes with the errant state? Obviously Walker's ultimate goal is not to punish Israel; it's to get them to behave in a way that best serves equality and international justice. But by keeping her book out of Israel, Walker is denying them one of the very tools that could help them to understand why these ends are so important.
"The Color Purple" tells the story of an impoverished and mistreated black girl in the American South. The novel preaches tolerance, diversity and racial equality, and it does so through narrative, often the most effective means of imparting a lesson to a human being.
Art like Walker's is often the first step toward making people realize that their own practices may be just as oppressive as the practices they see in the work of art. "The Color Purple" challenges the unjust status quo, just as the music of the Beatles championed personal freedom in the sixties and as Picasso's "Guernica" protested the bombing of Basque Country during the Spanish Civil War. If Walker truly believes Israel is an intolerant and inhumane nation, keeping "The Color Purple" from them will only hinder, not help her cause.
In an interview with Foreign Policy last year, Walker stated that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was "David and Goliath, but Goliath is not the Palestinians." David defeated Goliath with his slingshot, but the staunchly non-violent Walker wouldn't approve of such a solution. The logical conclusion? Someone needs to teach Goliath that bullying is not the solution. Goliath needs to read "The Color Purple."
Reach Contributor Francesca Bessey here.



Comments
"The Palestinians have the highest standard of living in the Arab world???"
You have to be kidding me! Walker is trying to boycott whether you like her method or not and these ignorant comments here is another reason why there is no hope when it comes to this situation. Also, stop bringing religion in to this.
Without expressing any support for the indefinite occupation of the West Bank or the settlements there, I fail to see how Israel is apartheid. Israeli Arabs have full civil rights and are represented in Israel at every level, including the Supreme Court. 2 Miss Israels have been Israeli-Arab, several members of the national soccer team are, several ambassadors and consuls abroad have been, a large part of the IDF officer corps, until recently the Minister of Science & Sport, the Director-General of the Interior Ministry, the Tel Aviv Income Tax Commissioner, about a fifth of Israel mayors and council members, a tenth of the Knesset parliament members, including the Deputy Speaker of the House and the list goes on. The West Bank is largely ruled by the Palestinian Authority, the Gaza Strip entirely by Hamas and although the present stalemate is hardly ideal, it does not resemble apartheid in any shape or form, as does not Northern Ireland, the Basque Country, Turkish Kurdistan, Ace in Indonesia or Mindanao in the Philippines. The Palestinians have the highest standard of living in the Arab world and enjoy far more civil rights and economic opportunity and education than a vast majority of it. Israel has a lot to answer for, as do the Palestinians, regarding the stalled peace process, but accusing it if apartheid reeks of racism, or rather of a specific type, an endemic type called antisemitism which refuses to disappear. Boycotting the Hebrew language would seem to be good prima facie evidence of that.
Ms Walker may be within her rights to withhold translation rights, but it just shows how ignorant she is.
Israel is far from apartheid and if Walker would visit she would learn the truth, far more complicated than those one-sided demagogues could ever imagine. The West Bank is indeed a thorny problem, but it is not Israel. The Palestinians are a self-governing entity who elected a recognized terrorist movement as their government. (Hamas, 2006) They proceeded to fight a civil war in the Gaza Strip, removing anyone interested in a dialogue with Israel.
Alice Walker was right not to let her book be published in Israel, its clearly a Racist Apartheid state. I've just bought her book and with all the good publicity she's getting she's sure to sell much more. As for the argument that the Israelis need to read the book, those that do need to read this book will see a picture of a black girl on the cover and think immigrant and refuse to read it and those who would read it dont need to as they clearly would not be racist.
Haha...what blatant Jew-Israel hate. Jew as Goliath, Nazi blah blah blah. Poor "underdog" Palestinians. A more haneous people have never walked the earth. With out shame before their supposed god "Allah" they celebrate their sons who slit the throats of babies in the middle of the night (Vogel family bloodbath anyone???). Color "purple" ??. More like color yellow.