Neon Tommy - Annenberg digital news

Supreme Court Takes On Affirmative Action

Tom Dotan |
February 21, 2012 | 2:53 p.m. PST


US Supreme Court courtesy of Creative Commons
US Supreme Court courtesy of Creative Commons

For the first time since 2007, the United States Supreme Court will examine a affirmative action suit, the outcome of which could deeply affect the future of the controversial policy.

The case, which won't be heard until the Fall, was filed in 2008 by a Texas woman who was not accepted into any of the University of Texas campuses.

Under a 1997 law, the state guarantees entrance to a UT campus to any student finishing within the top 10 percent of his class. Minority students who fall below that 10 percent are given preferential consideration.

Abigail Fisher's grades put her outside that top bracket, though she claims they were better than many minority students who got in. Fisher was inhumanely forced to go to her safety school, Louisiana State University, which was enough to maker her sue.

Supreme Court rulings on affirmative action are contentious and rare. The aforementioned 2007 ruling was about a law in Michigan similar to Texas' in regards to entrance to state universities. That decision was 5-4 with Justice Sandra Day O'Connor writing the majority opinion. O'Connor has since retired from the court and her replacement, Justice Samuel Alito has previously ruled against affirmative action.

Justice Elena Kagan, an Obama appointee, has announced that she will recuse herself from the case. That leaves eight justices, five of whom have been critical of "racial balancing" policies.


The case will be heard this October at the earliest.


Reach Tom Dotan here


Live On Twitter


Miu Miu layers on for this  spring.

Justin Wilcox will take his evolving USC defense and face his former squad on Thursday night



Anonymous (not verified) on February 28, 2012 10:41 AM

I call bullshit on her grades.
Maybe for UT Austin, but not for the others.

UT, as most colleges do, take your SATs and ACTs into account. If your grades don't let you get automatic admission, then you have to get a certain score on those tests depending on what percentile you are in.

If her grades were as good as she says then she must have gotten shitty scores on those test to not get in. Also, some UT schools take essays, so she might not have done up to their standards.