Neon Tommy - Annenberg digital news

"Cars 2" Review: Pixar Trades Charm For Violence

Whitney Bratton |
June 25, 2011 | 4:15 p.m. PDT

Staff Reporter

Explosions, violence, and Pixar, oh my! (Photo from teaser-trailer.com)
Explosions, violence, and Pixar, oh my! (Photo from teaser-trailer.com)
Pixar has built itself an enviable reputation as a reliable source of family friendly, high-quality storytelling, but when it comes to “Cars 2,” that wonderful Pixar charm somehow went amiss.

Where the first Pixar movie, “Cars,” got its power boost from a cast of loveable, quirky characters in small town Radiator Springs, “Cars 2” instead downshifts to rely on lowbrow humor, a heavy dose of spy movie tropes, and pacing designed to entertain even the most ADHD kid in the theater.

Most astonishing, though, was the prevalence of guns, bombs, electrocution, cars-beating-up-other-cars in the bathroom, and other generalized violence not especially appropriate for its G-rating.

Where the first "Cars" movie was all about slowing down and remembering that the journey is more important than the destination, "Cars 2" launches on a high-octane roadtrip across the globe, introducing new makes and models (with all their eccentricities), and engaging in a spy thriller premise completely at odds with the values of Cars 1.

The story opens with a James Bond style infiltration of a field of oil rigs by an Aston Martin named Finn McMissile (Michael Caine), who gets a glimpse of the villain, Professor Zündapp (Thomas Kretschmann), before narrowly escaping with the help of an arsenal of weapons and gadgets.

From there the story cuts back to the slow life in Radiator Springs, where the hero from Cars 1, the racecar Lightening McQueen (Owen Wilson), has just returned home with his fourth “Piston Cup” win.  Notably absent from the scene is his mentor from the first film, “Doc” Hudson, whose voice-actor Paul Newman has since passed away.

But the hero of "Cars 2" is not McQueen, it is the loveable rusty tow truck, Mater (Larry the Cable Guy), who played a comedic sidekick in the first film.  Mater has always been a strange truck, driving the thin line between annoying and innocent, but in "Cars 2" he crosses the median completely and his cluelessness and lack of social sophistication begin to (no pun intended) drive away his friends.

The story focuses on friendship and trust, but ultimately the message is confusing.  “Be yourself,” seems to be the official line, but what that means is uncertain: Mater comes across as irritating, crude, and prone to inappropriate outbursts—and the message is that this is okay so long as Mater isn’t faking it?

All this is not to say that "Cars 2" has no redeeming qualities.  There are a myriad of clever puns, plot twists, and one-liners (you’ve probably heard some of them already in the trailer).  The international atmosphere allows for a parade of unusual cars, both old and new, famous and obscure.  The global dialog surrounding renewable, alternative, and “green” fuel sources is appropriate to the times, and plays off both consumer and auto industry anxiety about making the switch from fossil fuel to electric powered engines.

The idea of integrating ‘lemons,’ (cars that never work quite the way they should), was ingenious, and allowed for a smattering of delightful mechanic technobabble to spill from Mater’s otherwise uneducated mouth and redeem him somewhat in terms of intelligence.

Even without paying extra for the 3D experience, "Cars 2’s" vibrant settings, both international and local, popped from the screen with lush lighting and texture.  The camera seemed to move effortlessly through a real-life world, and included an exhilarating flying-over-London scene that would put Peter Pan to shame.

"Cars 2" also included several celebrity cameos, disguised as cars of course, including NASCAR drivers Darrell Waltrip as Darrell Cartrip and Jeff Gordon as Jeff Gorvette; British racecar/Formula 1 drivers David Hobbs as David Hobbscap and Lewis Hamilton as himself; and sportscaster Brent Musburger as Brent Mustangburger.

This is a film for mechanics, NASCAR dads, car lovers, Bond fans and anyone who wants to spend an hour with Larry the Cable Guy.  Just don’t be surprised when Mater whips out a Gatling gun and starts firing indiscriminately into a crowd of Gremlins and Pacers.  After all, who hasn’t at some point in their life wanted to do just that when their car won’t start in the morning?

 

Contact Whitney Bratton here.



 

Live On Twitter

Buzz

A Portentous Election

Greuel and Garcetti have been mum on the city’s biggest economic issue. 

 


Comments

Anonymous (not verified) on December 15, 2011 11:19 AM

Way too violent!!!! Class action suit?????

Your rating: None
Anonymous (not verified) on June 26, 2011 4:55 PM

I went to see Cars 2 with my nieces and nephews, brother, sister-in-law, and my 22 year old son. We enjoyed the movie for the most part, but as yogamom pointed out, it is definitely not a movie for toddlers, and even my six year old niece was too young, as her mom pointed out. I was disappointed by the torture and killing scenes - very off kilter for Disney, and we are Disney fans and a Disney family. (going to their parks and watching their movies for years) Basically this is a movie about spy and espionage, and most definitely should have had a rating of at least PG, and adverstised as being for older children/teens. Your movie review (neontommy) is an accurate description, and the way I felt about the movie.

Your rating: None Average: 4 (2 votes)
Yogamom67 (not verified) on June 26, 2011 3:02 PM

Loved the movie - lots of authentic laughs and visually very appealing. Both my husband and our 6 yr old son were glued to the screen. Entirely too violent, however. A Disney movie, geared toward kids, should not show torture, bombings and killings, etc. Doesn't matter if it's a car or a muppet. Thought the film definitely should have been rated PG. No idea how this level of violence got a G rating. Also seemed like related marketing of merchandise played a a little too much into the storyline. It was still a lot of fun, tho - and I'm sure my husband will buy it on blue ray the second it comes out! A fun summer escape, but not suitable for the toddler crowd...

Your rating: None Average: 4 (2 votes)
John s. (not verified) on June 26, 2011 11:08 AM

Very disappointed with Cars 2. I wemt with my grandkids,3 and 5 years old. Too violent and too loud. I will not recommend it to others.

Your rating: None Average: 1.8 (4 votes)
Anonymous (not verified) on June 26, 2011 5:16 PM

Give me a freakin' break. Didn't any of you people grow up watching looney tunes? Did you enjoy Bugs Bunny and the Road Runner? Third Question: Did your enjoyment of those classics make you, as a child want to smash someone with a piano? Probably not. Forgive me, but I'm appalled by the overly cautious and borderline pacifist opinions I've read on this board. Too Violent my a$$.

Your rating: None Average: 4.7 (3 votes)
Anonymous (not verified) on June 27, 2011 8:16 AM

While I hesitate to feed the troll, I must say that Looney Tunes is not even remotely close to the violence shown in Cars 2. All of the violence in LT is light-hearted and silly slapstick type humor. There are no darkly lit scenes where Bugs Bunny is held down and tortured (and eventually killed) to extract information.

There are also no high powered, large caliber weapons in LT unless you count ACME rockets. The difference is stark and only a moron (like yourself) would fail to see the difference.

Your rating: None

Leave a comment

Name
E-mail*
URL
Comments*