2011 NFL Draft: Biggest Surprises

The Free Fall of Da’Quan Bowers
In the weeks leading up to the draft, the stock of Clemson defensive end Da’Quan Bowers took a serious hit due to concerns about the long-term health of his knee. Once projected to be a top 5 pick, and possibly No. 1 overall, many of the most recent draft boards saw Bowers fall to the fringes of the top 20.
Draft day proved to be an entirely different story.
Bowers was not taken in the top 20. He wasn’t taken in the first round at all. Instead, he fell all the way to the second round (51st overall) and was drafted by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. While concerns about his knee post-surgery were surely legitimate, there is no explanation for a player of Bowers’ talent and production falling so far in the draft. Getting Bowers this late was a huge steal for the Buccaneers. Assuming he stays healthy, the Bucs could have the youngest, most feared defensive line in the NFC South due to their acquisition of Gerald McCoy and Brian Price in last year’s draft.
Ridiculous First Round Quarterbacks
While there was nothing surprising about Cam Newton going with the first pick, the next few quarterbacks taken likely shocked NFL fans. At No. 8, the Tennessee Titans took Washington QB Jake Locker, and at No. 12, the Minnesota Vikings took Florida State QB Christian Ponder. Between those two, Jacksonville took Missouri QB Blaine Gabbert at No. 10.
Both Locker and Ponder are huge reaches.
Locker is incredibly athletic and has many of the physical tools required to be a great NFL quarterback, but he was nothing more than mediocre in college. His career completion percentage of 53.7% leaves much to be desired. While Locker wasn’t surrounded by elite talent while at Washington, he rarely made the players around him better as great quarterbacks do. Depending on how he pans out, the Titans could set back their playoff contention by a number of years.
Ponder, on the other hand, was not a pick made out of desire. The Vikings were backed into taking him when they decided to give the franchise to Brett Favre. Now, they find themselves in the unenviable position of having drafted a quarterback who many thought would go in the second round.
While Ponder was a great leader for Florida State, he lost much of his arm strength following surgery for a separated shoulder in 2009. He may turn out to be a great starter for the Vikings, as he was highly regarded prior to his shoulder injury. However, his potential is lessened due to his diminished arm strength.
Atlanta Trades Up For Julio Jones
The Atlanta Falcons took a huge risk by drafting Julio Jones sixth.
While Jones is a tremendous talent at receiver, the move to get him cost the Falcons their first, second and fourth round picks in this draft, as well as their first and fourth round picks in the 2012 draft. Giving up all of these picks signifies boldness on the part of the Atlanta brass.
Instead of strengthening the team through multiple picks, Atlanta is betting the farm on Jones.
With him, Atlanta goes from being a perennial playoff contender to a potential Super Bowl contender in a suddenly interesting NFC South. However, if Jones doesn’t produce like he’s expected to opposite Roddy White, this move could be seen as the first in a series of justifications for a change in the Falcons’ leadership.
_______________
Reach Daniel by email.



Comments
I agree with GRD. Cam Newton is the reach here. That team is now in shambles. However, because he was the media's consensus #1, you say there was nothing surprising there. It's always surprising when the #1 pick Is wasted on a one year wonder. Locker will be solid and Tennessee, right now, is already worlds ahead of Carolina, due to their #1picks.
Locker was tremendous in college. Do your homework.
Washington was already the worst team in the PAC10 when Locker committed to play there because of the complete Ty Willingham disaster. TW wrecked the ND & UW programs.
He also was the ONLY coach in the PAC10 to NIT have a QB coach on his staff!!!
Sarkisian took over a team that went 0-12 due to Locker's smashed hand (TW used him as a throwing fullback).
In 2 years, Sarkisian coached Locker to be a pro-style QB and lead his team to the #3 in the PAC - in 2 years!
Locker also played 4 games in 2010 with broken ribs. (on his throwing side) and 3 games so sick with the flu/bronchitis that Sark could not call running plays, so defenses t'd off on Locker.
The Titans did their homework. 4 other teams (especially Shanahan) tried desperately to trade up for Locker.
I can't stand these East coast writers who never do any research and just are another Mel Kiper (does he look stupid now or what? He called the whole draft wrong).
The biggest mistake - Cam Newton.
He played ONE season in college, went to school for ONE quarter, got arrested, cheated off other students, and obviously got paid to play at Auburn. The guy is arrogant and no leader.
Did you see the Gruden interview? He couldn't even call a play when asked.
The next Ryan Leaf/Jamarcus Russell. HUGE mistake.
Locker will be the standout QB of this class for years...
Kiper Jr's only "talent" is that regardless of whatever he predicts, exact opposite will almost assuredly come to fruition. This is true with regards to both the players he recommends and those he claims are certain to fail. I find it comical each year before the draft as ESPN airs their "draft genius'" comments that people ACTUALLY CONTINUE TO LISTEN TO HIM?!??! He has an uncanny track record of having completely NO IDEA WHATSOEVER AS TO WHAT IS GOING ON. YEAH I BET THAT THE TEAMS ARE CONSULTING HIM BEFORE EACH ONE OF THEIR PICKS ASKING HIS EXPERT OPINION. LOL. THE STUPID OCTOPUS THAT PREDICTED WORLD CUP MATCH WINNERS AT THE LAST WORLD CUP WOULD BE 64 TIMES MORE ACCURATE IN PROJECTING THE TOP 25 DRAFT CHOICES. #STUPIDMELKIPER