Neon Tommy - Annenberg digital news

Using Sexism To Explain Drinking Patterns

Stephanie McNeal |
July 14, 2010 | 2:09 p.m. PDT

Staff Reporter

A new report suggests that teenage girls are more likely to drink to relieve stress or deal with problems, while teenage boys mostly drink to loosen up in social situations or to have fun.

Teenage girls are also drinking more than teenage boys, according to the study, which was conducted among 3,287 teens in private and public high schools by the Partnership for a Drug-Free America. 

In the past year, 59% of high school girls admitted to drinking, whereas only 52% of high school boys did. The number of girls increased by 11%  in the past year alone.

A recently published article in Newsweek attempts to explain this phenomenon. 

One theory is that there are more alcoholic products geared toward girls nowadays. These drinks--I assume they are referring to girl favorites like Mike’s Hard Lemonade and Smirnoff Ice--tend to be more sugary and are usually also available in female-friendly diet flavors.

The article also notes that more girls are reportedly drinking because “girls are more sensitive to emotional stress” and tend to internalize things. 

I know this study is based on apparently verified statistical information, but I just can’t agree with the image it provides.

From reading this article, one would think that high school girls are sitting in their rooms downing shots by themselves to deal with their emotional problems, while high school boys are out drinking and having fun. And the reason for this is because girls are more sensitive and can’t handle their day-to-day lives? I just don’t see it.

The author does make a concession at the end that girls may be more mature and more willing to admit their reasons for drinking than boys, but this again relies on simple gender stereotypes.

The information presented in this article is certainly worrisome, but to blame it on women’s inability to handle their own emotions is a little simplistic and sexist.

However, many of the comments on a USA Today story on the same subject noted that this problem may be a result of a selfish society.

Their argument? Today’s teens are overly stressed because they are too focused on themselves and their own lives. Instead of focusing on others, they turn to alcohol and drugs to deal with their own concerns.

One commenter even blamed Facebook for this phenomenon: “Facebook is making a whole generation of kids not deal with people/problems. Not deal with real life experiences. To them, having 100's of ‘friends,’ a cool web-page and chatting about inane nonsense is their priority in life. And when the ‘you-know-what’ hits the fan, they are emotionally ill-equipped to handle the situation.”

Other commenters said it was more likely that kids were just trying to get a thrill and that trying to find some sort of gender-based explanation for it was a waste of time.

"I tend to agree that stress and coping are just rationalizations," one commented. "Teens see these excuses used to justify all kinds of behavior, so why shouldn't they use the same excuses?"

So are today’s girls really turning to alcohol more than previous generations to deal with problems, or are they just trying to get a thrill like many generations before them? 

It’s hard to know for sure, but it’s certainly not an issue that can be explained away by a simple generalization based on gender or society.

Reach reporter Stephanie McNeal here.

Photo credit: Douglas Muth



 

Buzz

New Romney Ad Courts Hispanic Vote

The Romney Campaign looks to engage Hispanic voters with its new advertisement.

L.A. Galaxy Stumble To First “SuperClasico” Loss In Five Years Against Chivas USA

The Galaxy are now winless in their last five matches.

 

Best way to find more great content from Neon Tommy?


Or join our email list below to enjoy  Neon Tommy News Alerts.


Comments

AnaC (not verified) on July 23, 2010 3:00 AM

Fantastic analysis Stephanie! This is the kind of commentary we need more of in today's media!

Your rating: None
Stephanie McNeal (not verified) on July 27, 2010 11:58 AM

Thanks so much!

Your rating: None
Anonymous (not verified) on July 15, 2010 7:54 PM

Such a little feminist! Way to prove the article right and get all emotional about something small.

Fact: Women tend to be more emotional than men.

So what? If you're different, that's great, but your whole article whines about a scientific, genetic and cultural fact. The article didn't say, as you so dramatically took it, that girls "can’t handle their day-to-day lives."

It said (full quote here), "Girls tend to be more sensitive to emotional stress, neurologically. Girls mature a little bit earlier in parts of the brain; boys develop later in those areas."

How offensive! The reader would think girls throw hissy fits every time they don't get what they want, right? Or every time they read a Newsweek article that intrudes on their own ignorant, closed-minded preconceptions?

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)
Stephanie McNeal (not verified) on July 17, 2010 8:19 AM

Hey Anonymous,
I dont really consider myself a feminist. When I read this article, it didnt make a lot of sense to me because no one I know drinks because of emotional problems, they drink to have fun and to be social, as the article said guys do. So I just dont really agree with this survey or the article, and I thought the explanation it gave was a little simplistic. But thats just my opinion, obviously you have a different one! And as I pointed out, a lot of people that commented had different theories as well. My overall point that I was trying to make was that I dont think you can use one blanket statement to explain individual girls' drinking habits.

Your rating: None

Leave a comment

Name
E-mail*
URL
Comments*